Use Coupon Code ILOVEJENIUS for 10% off

How does Bing’s voice search evaluate to Google’s?


Google stays the dominant participant in search advertising, however the business is altering very quickly and the previous certainties might erode. Does voice search present a platform for Microsoft to compete?

A research earlier this 12 months revealed that Microsoft’s speech recognition know-how demonstrated solely a 5.1 % phrase error fee in Switchboard, a conversational speech recognition job. This exhibits spectacular growth and exhibits that Microsoft is greater than aggressive on this area, however it is just a part of the image.

Speech recognition and voice recognition are considerably totally different. The previous extracts phrases and comprehends what is alleged; the latter additionally perceive who stated it. We may body this as content material and context.

Context would be the defining think about who turns into the dominant participant in voice search, with an rising quantity of internet-enabled gadgets offering the chance for a seamless, conversational expertise.

Little doubt, search is on the very coronary heart of this battle.

Bing has positioned itself as merely a more practical search engine, with campaigns like Bing It On geared toward displaying customers the standard of its outcomes in comparison with these of Google.


Often we see tales of spectacular person progress for Bing, however by no means fairly sufficient to recommend a major menace to Google’s totemic stature. Newest estimates from Good Insights put Google’s world share of the search market at 77%, with Bing on about eight%.

The indicators up to now recommend that Google will stay the dominant search participant within the West, however the sands are shifting and it’s more and more troublesome to foretell the place the business will go. With a newly-announced partnership with Amazon’s Alexa, Microsoft is clearly not going to surrender the combat.

So, if search is the glue that holds this collectively, what’s Microsoft’s technique to compete with Google? We all know Microsoft’s speech recognition know-how is efficient, however how do its voice search capabilities stack up?

Microsoft voice search: the important thing particulars

Microsoft’s digital assistant, Cortana, is embedded into Home windows-enabled gadgets and into Microsoft’s Edge web browser. That gives entry to over half a billion customers, as soon as we think about Microsoft’s Xbox gaming consoles.

Cortana has a large number of makes use of. It helps customers navigate the Home windows interface and might reply to a large number of wider queries, powered by Microsoft’s Bing search engine, for instance.

In fact, cellular is a core focus and due to this fact Cortana is offered through a spread of Microsoft cellular and software program.

Like different digital assistants, Cortana is at all times able to reply queries on a Home windows machine. It now prompts customers to check its broadening functionalities by pushing notifications like “Ask me to remind you to purchase eggs subsequent time you’re on the grocery store” or “Would you prefer to know which tune is taking part in?”

It may be a bit creepy and intrusive, however for probably the most half customers will solely actually discover Cortana when they should use it. The listing of prompts is kind of formulaic and Cortana merely searches a question on Bing when it could’t perceive what the person desires.

Cortana voice commands

All of this performance is at its greatest when a person is logged in throughout a spread of Microsoft gadgets, nonetheless. The identical is true of any digital assistant, however the the respective circumstances of Apple and Google that is merely extra prone to happen.

Which means Cortana misses out on very important context, not by way of any technological shortcoming, however moderately by way of the dearth of mass adoption of Microsoft’s .

On the software program entrance, Microsoft fares higher. There at the moment are over 100 million month-to-month customers of Cortana through Home windows 10, and the newest version of the Edge browser continues to deliver voice search to the fore.

That is nonetheless not fairly sufficient to make a major dent in Google’s lead, nonetheless. One of the vital searched-for technology-based phrases on Bing is [google], in spite of everything.

Microsoft’s voice search technique

The problem for Microsoft has at all times been to achieve sufficient of the precious cellular software program market to compete with Apple and Google.

The place Apple controls a really worthwhile part of each the and software program ecosystems, Google has traditionally targeted on its Android OS as a Computer virus to make sure continued use of its merchandise on a variety of gadgets.

With Google House, the Google Pixel smartphone, and Google’s soon-to-be-completed buy of Taiwanese smartphone firm HTC, the main focus has shifted to because the Web of Issues comes of age.

Microsoft’s Invoke good speaker ensures it has a seat on the desk, however it’s the partnership with Amazon’s extremely profitable Echo audio system that ought to improve utilization numbers for Cortana.


Microsoft has at all times fared effectively within the enterprise market (albeit underneath rising competitors from Apple and Google right here, too), however the private smartphone market has been tougher to interrupt.

Additional integrations with fashionable platforms reminiscent of Spotify, to associate with Microsoft’s possession of Skype, may begin to place Cortana as an interesting different to the walled backyard strategy of Apple.

How does Microsoft voice search differ from Google voice search?

Though each perform in comparable methods, there are some core areas of differentiation:

  • Speech recognition: Cortana does this fantastically effectively and, though Google Assistant continues to be very correct, small margins do matter on this enviornment. Though solely a pattern dimension of 1, I may also attest that Cortana comprehends my Irish brogue rather more precisely than Google Assistant.
  • Enterprise job administration: Cortana is usually a enormous timesaver with instructions like “Pull up the newest model of my job tracker.” With full entry to the Home windows OS, it could find paperwork fairly simply and cut back time spent on laborious doc looking out.
  • Context: When a person is logged in throughout Home windows merchandise, Cortana can serve correct contextual outcomes. See beneath for an instance of the identical phrase searched by voice on a Home windows laptop computer utilizing Cortana and Google:


The variations are slight, however telling. Cortana is aware of that I’m at present in Spain (I’m utilizing a Home windows laptop computer), and due to this fact offers the kick-off in my native time. Google shouldn’t be aware about this data and serves the lead to Jap Time, as my account is predicated within the US.

When outcomes default to Bing, all of it will get somewhat hairier.

I observe up by asking who might be within the beginning lineup and obtain a weird end result concerning the USA soccer workforce, a information story a couple of Leeds beginning lineup from three years in the past, and a few information concerning the Leeds music pageant.

Leeds line-up

Google does a greater job of this, however each lack the immediacy that integration with a social media feed would supply:
Google Leeds

This similar sample performs out throughout a variety of journey, climate, and business queries. When Cortana can pull a direct reply, it does so very capably; when it resorts to offering a listing of search outcomes from Bing, the standard varies. Google due to this fact represents a way more constant, dependable choice.

The brand new partnership with Amazon might open a spread of avenues for Microsoft to succeed in a wider viewers, which can solely assist to refine these suggestions. For the second, Google’s superior search expertise stays its trump card within the battle for digital assistant supremacy.

In abstract

A graphic comparing the voice search capabilities of Microsoft and Google, respectively. Under the Microsoft section, the pros are listed as: speech recognition, ecommerce offering via Amazon, and Skype integration. The cons are listed as: voice recognition, lack of third-party integrations, and Bing search results. The devices which support Microsoft voice search are listed as: Microsoft devices, Windows 10 and Microsoft Edge. Under the Google section, the pros are listed as: context recognition, linked to all Google products, and Google search. The cons are listed as: speech recognition is flawed, shopping offering is a work in progress. The devices which support Google voice search are listed as: Android devices, Google Chrome and Chromebooks.

Picture created by Clark Boyd

Leave a Reply